The Time and attendance recording has been the case since the rulings of the European Court of Justice (ECJ) and the Federal Labour Court (BAG) on the most widely discussed topics in employment law. Many companies are faced with the question of what obligations already exist and how time recording can be implemented in practice in a legally compliant manner.
Even though new legislation has yet to be introduced, this by no means implies that employers can afford to delay implementing such a system. On the contrary, current case law suggests that there is already an obligation to record working hours.
Is there an obligation to record working hours?
The obligation to Time and attendance recording refers to a judgement of the ECJ dating from 2019. The Court ruled that Member States must require employers to put in place an objective, reliable and accessible system for recording daily working hours.
The Federal Labour Court (BAG) took up these principles in 2022 and clarified that employers are already obliged under current German law to record their employees’ working hours. The basis for this is Section 3(2)(1) of the Occupational Health and Safety Act.
This means that, regardless of any future specific legal provisions, there is already an obligation to record working hours.
Which working hours need to be recorded?
The aim of working time recording is to ensure compliance with statutory working time regulations.
In particular, the following should be recorded:
- Start of the working day
- End of the working day
- Length of the daily working hours
- overtime worked
- statutory rest periods
Comprehensive documentation not only provides legal certainty, but also makes it easier to provide evidence to the authorities or in employment tribunal proceedings.
How should working hours be recorded?
Contrary to a widely held belief, the law currently states no specific system before.
Employers can record working hours, for example, by:
Digital time and attendance systems
Electronic systems enable simple and transparent documentation and can often be integrated with existing HR systems.
Time-tracking apps
Apps offer a practical solution, particularly for mobile working or field work.
Manual documentation
Handwritten or tabular records may also, in principle, be sufficient, provided they are complete, comprehensible and reliably maintained.
The choice of system should be based on the size of the company, its operational processes and the relevant working models.
Who is required to record their working hours?
In principle, the obligation to Time and attendance recording almost all employees.
Although the actual recording of working hours may be delegated to employees, the responsibility for ensuring that working hours are in fact properly documented remains with the employer.
Specific issues may arise, amongst other things, in relation to senior executives or members of governing bodies, such as managing directors. Depending on their role and legal classification, different provisions under working time legislation may apply in some cases.
Even in the case of Working from home, remote working or trust-based working arrangements do not, in principle, remove the obligation to record working hours. On the contrary, modern working models in particular make transparent documentation essential.
Common mistakes in practice
In many companies, there is still uncertainty regarding the implementation of time and attendance systems.
Common mistakes include:
- missing or incomplete time records
- Recording of overtime only
- No documentation required for working from home or on the move
- lack of monitoring of recorded working hours
- no internal policies on time recording
These omissions may not only contravene health and safety regulations, but may also lead to significant problems in terms of evidence in the event of a dispute.
Practical tip: Establish processes at an early stage
Employers should Time and attendance recording should not be viewed merely as a legal obligation, but as an integral part of modern human resources management.
Clear internal guidelines, suitable digital systems and regular training ensure that working hours are documented transparently and that statutory maximum working hours and rest periods are reliably adhered to. At the same time, this significantly reduces the likelihood of subsequent disputes over overtime or pay claims.
Conclusion
The obligation to Time and attendance recording already exists today. Employers should therefore not wait for new legislation, but should review existing processes and adapt them where necessary.
A transparent and reliable time-recording system not only provides legal certainty, but also improves operational organisation and reduces risks relating to employment law. Those who structure their processes at an early stage will be well prepared for future legislative developments.
If you have any questions on this or other topics, please contact us - we will be happy to advise you.
to the contact form